apple ipad 3 event New iPad Performance Disappoints: Peacekeeper Benchmark Scores Remain the Same

While Apple did an untypical thing and attacked NVIDIA and their Tegra 3 quad-core chip, claiming 4x better performance, the first benchmark results tell a different story, especially in Futuremark’s Peacekeeper benchmark.

Firstly, Notebook Magazine ran an article in which editors compared the New iPad  (iPad 3) and ASUS Eee Pad Transformer Prime, powered by NVIDIA Tegra 3 processor. In their comparison, they did find a benchmark or two where Apple’s A5X chip managed to beat NVIDIA Tegra 3 but in all honesty, there were benchmarks in which A5X got hammered by Tegra 3. If I was CEO of NVIDIA, I could not be happier for the amount of free PR given by Tim Cooke and the fruity gang.

Now, Futuremark is joining the fold, comparing the New iPad to existing batch of tablets with surprising results. Given that Apple did not give any processing power boost between A5 and A5X, it is not surprising to hear that performance in HTML5 and JavaScript-based Peacekeeper did not move by an inch.

Futuremark Peacekeeper chrome New iPad Performance Disappoints: Peacekeeper Benchmark Scores Remain the Same

According to the company, “Peacekeeper takes 5 minutes to run during which time it evaluates the browser’s performance with a rendering test, WebGL test, HTML5 video test, HTML5 canvas test, HTML5 web worker test, data manipulation tests, DOM operations test and text parsing tests. For more detailed explanations of these tests see the FAQ: http://peacekeeper.futuremark.com/faq.action”

And if you wonder what the scores are, the results are here:

  • Acer Iconia W500 (Windows 8 CP, AMD Fusion E-Series) – Peacekeeper score 405
  • Apple iPad 3rd gen (iOS 5.1, Apple A5X) – Peacekeeper score 384
  • Apple iPad 2 (iOS 5.1, Apple A5) – Peacekeeper score 383
  • Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1 (Android 4.0.1, NVIDIA Tegra 2) – Peacekeeper score 356
  • ASUS Eee Pad Transformer Prime (Android 4.0.3, NVIDIA Tegra 3) – Peacekeeper score 344
  • Apple iPad 1st gen (iOS 5.1, Apple A4) – Peacekeeper score 234

Yes, it is odd seing Tegra 2-based tablet beating the Tegra 3-based one, but that is not surprising, given the load on the internal bus. Still, the difference in clock (T20 operates at 1GHz, T30 operates at 1.3GHz) should give better results. Pleasant surprise is AMD powered Acer W500, which leads the tablet pack. As the picture above clearly suggests, tablets from 2011 and 2012 are still around 10 times slower than a standard gaming PC from 2009.